The New Legislative Map Must be Non-partisan!
Gerrymandered redistricting is extremely destructive to the foundation of America’s democracy – government by the people based on the vote. I urge the Redistricting Commission to do everything in their power to create a fair and unbiased map to help Pennsylvania emerge from its current devisive status. A partisan redistricted map will only stir more hostility and lack of trust. Please carefully consider the points below as articulated by Representative Wendi Thomas: The map chills competition: The Princeton Gerrymandering Project gave the proposed map an F grade on competitiveness. Dave’s Redistricting App, a website dedicated to creating and analyzing district maps, says the proposed map is 27 percent less competitive than the current districts. (By comparison, the proposed Senate map received a C grade from the Princeton Gerrymandering Project). Districts are not compact: While Pennsylvania has some obvious geographic challenges to compactness, the proposed map is 28 percent and 30 percent less compact than the current map based on the Polsby-Popper and Reock scales, respectively. It is weak on population equity: Our state Constitution mandates each district have approximately the same number of residents, and per the U.S. Supreme Court, the commonly accepted deviation from this standard is 5 percent over or under the ideal population size and 10 percent for the overall map. The proposed map just squeaks in at 9.28 percent, meaning there is wide variation in district populations leaving some citizens underserved and others over-served. It utilizes purely partisan tools to achieve its goals: The new districts in Bucks County are “packed.” As I learned in my work on fair redistricting, “packing” is when you put as many voters from a party into a district to make it “safe” for that party, to make other districts safer for the other party. The new maps split Northampton Township by putting three districts in Langhorne. Northampton has one fire department and one police department, and is in one school district. There is no logical reason to break up Northampton Township. One might think I would be happy with this proposed map as my district has been packed with more of my own party, making it far less competitive. But as someone who has long fought for fairness in redistricting, I am not. As a constituent who has been dedicated to redistricting reform said, “I have worked on this project for over five years, and I am so disheartened.” The proposed legislative map is not good for our residents, our state or our country. It only continues to sow the division that is hurting our communities. Thank you, Marcia Garb – 47 year resident of Buck County